603 - 5885 1250 (4 lines) info@mes100.com
View Categories

What a One-Dimensional Drainage Model Can Tell Us About Flow Turning in a Sump

What can we calculate? #

Water enters a sump, turns through 90 degrees, and leaves through another drain. We can see the turn on plan. How much does it raise the upstream water level, and how hard does the water push against the sump?

A one-dimensional drainage model can calculate the effect of an assumed sump loss on the connected network. From its flow and velocity results, we can also calculate energy loss and momentum change. However, the model gives the sump one hydraulic head; it cannot tell us how pressure or water level varies from one wall to another.

In this article we will work through these calculations, then use worked examples to show what an engineer can decide from them. Local water-level rise is covered separately in The Superelevation Equation for Flow Through Curved Conduits.

Water level, head and the flow section #

Elevation, pressure head, HGL and EGL at a section Left: a full pipe with a piezometer. The elevation z of the measuring point plus the pressure head p over rho g reaches the hydraulic grade line, and the velocity head reaches the energy grade line above it. Right: an open channel, where the same sum reaches the water surface, so the hydraulic grade line is the water surface.Full pipeOpen channelVzp/ρgV²/2gHHGLEGLCommon elevation datumzp/ρgV²/2gHHGL = water surfaceEGLCommon elevation datum

Head expresses energy per unit weight of water as a height, in metres. At a pipe or channel section, let z be the elevation of the point where gauge pressure p is measured, \rho the water density, and g gravitational acceleration. Gauge pressure is measured relative to atmospheric pressure. The hydraulic grade line (HGL) is the elevation

H=z+pρg.H=z+\frac{p}{\rho g}.
(1)

All elevations are measured above the same project datum: the zero used by project ground, invert and water levels. For open-channel flow with approximately hydrostatic pressure, HGL is the water-surface elevation (WSE). In a full pipe, it is the height water would reach in a piezometer connected to the pipe. Thus a gravity drainage network can still have pressurised sections when it surcharges.

The energy grade line (EGL) also includes the kinetic energy of the moving water. If V is the mean speed at the section, its elevation is

H+V22g.H+\frac{V^2}{2g}.
(2)

We use a velocity-head correction factor of one in these bulk calculations. This treats the section velocity as uniform; it does not describe the fast jet and slower recirculating water that may coexist inside a sump.

For the calculations below, Q is discharge in m³/s, A is wetted flow area in m², and V=Q/A is mean speed in m/s. Subscripts i and o mean inlet and outlet. We use positive flow magnitudes along the actual flow direction, with g=9.81\ \text{m/s}^2 and \rho=1000\ \text{kg/m}^3 .

MiTS stores signed link flows. Those signs must be checked before identifying which link carries water into or out of the sump. The equations below assume one active inlet and one active outlet. Flow reversal or several simultaneous inflows need separate treatment; total node inflow alone does not tell us the direction or momentum of each stream.

How the sump loss changes the network calculation #

From the plan angle to the loss coefficient #

The deflection angle, \delta , is the change in flow direction on plan: zero for straight-through flow and 90 degrees for a right-angle turn.

Plan deflection angle and HEC-22 interior angle Flow enters from the left and leaves at 45 degrees above the straight continuation. Delta is 45 degrees; the interior angle is 135 degrees. Unit tangents follow the flow. Plan view · example: δ = 45° δ Interior angle = 135° tᵢ → sumptₒ → outlet Straight continuation Sump Angle → loss coefficient δ = cos⁻¹(tᵢ · tₒ) 45° deflection gives K = 0.75 Use the deflection column below. tᵢ and tₒ have unit length. Interior angle = 180° − δ

Let \boldsymbol t_i and \boldsymbol t_o be unit vectors along the adjacent drain segments, pointing towards and away from the sump respectively. Their dot product gives

ti⋅to=cos⁡δ,δ=cos⁡−1(ti⋅to).\boldsymbol t_i\cdot\boldsymbol t_o=\cos\delta, \qquad \delta=\cos^{-1}(\boldsymbol t_i\cdot\boldsymbol t_o).
(3)

The vectors must have length one. Otherwise their dot product includes the segment lengths as well as the angle. Software also limits a rounded dot product to the interval from −1 to 1 before taking the inverse cosine.

MiTS uses the following access-hole values from HEC-22 for its automatic preliminary loss calculation. HEC-22 measures the interior angle between the pipes, which is 180^\circ-\delta under this convention.

Deflection \delta Interior angle Loss coefficient K
0° 180° 0.15, adopted from the stated minimum
22.5° 157.5° 0.45
45° 135° 0.75
60° 120° 0.85
90° 90° 1.00

The dimensionless coefficient K expresses the loss as a multiple of the outlet velocity head. These are preliminary access-hole estimates; benching, depth, plunging inflow and unequal pipe sizes can change the actual loss. HEC-22, Fourth Edition, Sections 9.1.6.6–9.1.6.7 and Table 9.4.

Between two table entries, MiTS interpolates linearly. Let \delta_0 and \delta_1 be the lower and upper table angles bracketing the actual angle \delta , with coefficients K_0 and K_1 . The subscripts 0 and 1 identify table endpoints, not inlet and outlet. The fraction of the interval travelled is (\delta-\delta_0)/(\delta_1-\delta_0) , so

K=K0+δ−δ0δ1−δ0(K1−K0).K=K_0+\frac{\delta-\delta_0}{\delta_1-\delta_0}(K_1-K_0).
(4)

For a 30-degree turn,

K=0.45+30−22.545−22.5(0.75−0.45)=0.55.K=0.45+\frac{30-22.5}{45-22.5}(0.75-0.45)=0.55.
(5)

The automatic method does not extrapolate beyond 90 degrees. Also notice that straight-through flow still has a coefficient of 0.15: expansion, contraction and mixing in the chamber can consume energy even without a turn.

From the coefficient to head loss #

The kinetic energy per unit mass is V_o^2/2 . Dividing by g converts it to energy per unit weight, or velocity head, h_{V,o} . The head loss, h_L , is then

hV,o=Vo22g,hL=KhV,o=KVo22g.h_{V,o}=\frac{V_o^2}{2g}, \qquad h_L=K h_{V,o}=K\frac{V_o^2}{2g}.
(6)
Energy and hydraulic grade lines through a sump Long section from an inlet section through a sump to an outlet section. The energy grade line drops by the head loss across the sump. The hydraulic grade line lies one velocity head below it at each section. The outlet is drawn slower than the inlet, so the hydraulic grade line falls by less than the head loss.Vi²/2gVo²/2ghLHiHoCommon elevation datumEGLHGLSumpInletOutletDrawn with the outlet slower than the inlet, so HGL falls by less than hL.

To see what this means for water levels, consider steady flow between inlet and outlet sections, with no pump or turbine, as drawn above. If h_L accounts for the loss between those sections, the energy balance is

Hi+Vi22g=Ho+Vo22g+hL.H_i+\frac{V_i^2}{2g}=H_o+\frac{V_o^2}{2g}+h_L.
(7)

Rearranging gives

Hi−Ho=hL+Vo2−Vi22g.H_i-H_o=h_L+\frac{V_o^2-V_i^2}{2g}.
(8)

Only when the two speeds are equal does the HGL difference equal the head loss. In a network, adding a sump loss can change both levels and flows, so we rerun the network to find the result.

We include the sump loss in the network’s energy calculation and solve the connected flows and water levels together. The calculation must account for both local losses and downstream backwater. Each physical loss should be included once.

The resulting HGL already includes the applied loss. Calculating h_L afterwards tells us how much loss that coefficient represents at the reported speed; adding it to the HGL again would double-count it. MiTS’s automatic angle calculation uses the connected plan geometry. The sump width does not enter this angle-only coefficient.

Checking the rim clearance #

Let z_r be the rim elevation and t time. Time in the rate equations below is in seconds; report timestamps are displayed in minutes. The vertical clearance between the rim and the node HGL is

m(t)=zr−H(t),mmin⁡=zr−max⁡tH(t).m(t)=z_r-H(t), \qquad m_{\min}=z_r-\max_t H(t).
(9)
Rim elevation, node head and rim clearanceSection through a sump. Rim elevation z r and hydraulic head H are measured from the same datum. Their difference is rim clearance m. The modelled water level is drawn flat. Section through the sump Common elevation datum RimNode HGL, H(t) m(t)H(t)zᵣ m(t) = zᵣ − H(t) Positive m: below the rim. Zero: at the rim.Negative: above the rim. Smallest m: at maximum H(t) The flat line represents the node head; local waves and outer-wall rise are unresolved.

This is the quantity labelled Rim Clearance Above HGL in the sump summary; H(t) is the node HGL, written H_node in the local-rise formulas. We compare m_{\min} with the project’s required clearance. A positive clearance only establishes that the modelled head stays below the rim; if the project requires 150 mm freeboard, a 70 mm clearance still fails that requirement. Surcharge means water has risen above the relevant pipe crown and may occur while the sump remains below its rim. Flooding is a separate model output and depends on the node’s overflow and ponding settings.

What else can we calculate from the flow results? #

The loss coefficient K enters the hydraulic calculation and can change the node HGL. The loss power P_L and momentum-flux change M below are calculated afterwards from the flow results. Neither is needed for the HGL or rim-clearance check, and neither is fed back as an additional loss.

We can use them to compare layouts. To turn loss power into an erosion check, we would also need a method relating dissipation to the material and the area exposed. Momentum-flux change enters a force balance, but a structural check also needs the other forces and their distribution. If the question is simply whether the network has enough capacity and freeboard, these two calculations are optional.

Power dissipated by the sump loss #

Head loss is energy lost per unit weight of water. A discharge Q_o carries mass at a rate \rho Q_o , and weight at a rate \rho gQ_o . Multiplying this by the head loss in Equation (6) gives the loss power, P_L :

PL=(ρgQo)hL=ρgQoKVo22g.P_L=(\rho gQ_o)h_L=\rho gQ_oK\frac{V_o^2}{2g}.
(10)

The units are N/s multiplied by m, giving watts. At the same flow and speed, a larger K means more power dissipated. However, total power alone does not tell us where that energy is dissipated or over what area, so it cannot establish whether a wall or lining will erode.

Momentum change through the turn #

Water can change momentum by changing direction even if its speed stays the same. We therefore need velocity vectors, \boldsymbol V_i and \boldsymbol V_o , as well as discharge. We take the momentum correction factor as one, consistent with the mean-velocity approximation above.

Momentum carried through a section per second is mass flow rate multiplied by velocity. The outgoing amount minus the incoming amount is

M=ρQoVo−ρQiVi.\boldsymbol M=\rho Q_o\boldsymbol V_o-\rho Q_i\boldsymbol V_i.
(11)

Here \boldsymbol M is the momentum-flux change and M=|\boldsymbol M| its magnitude. For approximately equal discharges Q_i=Q_o=Q and speeds |\boldsymbol V_i|=|\boldsymbol V_o|=V ,

M=ρQ∣Vo−Vi∣.M=\rho Q|\boldsymbol V_o-\boldsymbol V_i|.
(12)
Velocity vectors and their difference through a turn Left: flow enters a turn with velocity V i and leaves with velocity V o, deflected by delta. Right: the two vectors drawn from one point, both of length V, with V o minus V i closing the triangle.Plan view of the turnSame vectors, from one pointViVoδSumpViVoVo − Viδ

For a horizontal turn through \delta , the figure shows the two vectors and their difference. Expanding the squared vector difference gives

∣Vo−Vi∣2=V2+V2−2V2cos⁡δ=2V2(1−cos⁡δ).|\boldsymbol V_o-\boldsymbol V_i|^2=V^2+V^2-2V^2\cos\delta=2V^2(1-\cos\delta).
(13)

Using 1-\cos\delta=2\sin^2(\delta/2) and taking the square root gives

M=2ρQVsin⁡(δ2).M=2\rho QV\sin\left(\frac{\delta}{2}\right).
(14)

Thus a straight path gives zero momentum change under these equal-flow, equal-speed assumptions, while a 90-degree turn gives M=\sqrt{2}\rho QV . If the inlet and outlet speeds differ, use Equation (11) instead of the equal-speed result in Equation (14). A plunging inlet also requires its vertical velocity component; a plan angle cannot describe that impact.

But can we use M as the force on the wall? To see what is missing, take a fixed control volume enclosing the water inside the sump:

Control volume enclosing the water in a sump Plan view of a sump with a dashed control volume just inside the walls. Water enters with velocity V i and leaves with velocity V o. Pressure forces F p act on the water at both openings, and the walls and floor act on the water with force F w. The weight W acts vertically.ViVoFpFpFwW (into the plan)Dashed line: control volumeFw is drawn in one direction only.Its true direction and how it spreadsover the walls need more information.

The momentum balance is

Fw+Fp+W=ddt∫CVρv dV+M.\boldsymbol F_w+\boldsymbol F_p+\boldsymbol W=\frac{d}{dt}\int_{\mathrm{CV}}\rho\boldsymbol v\,d\mathcal V+\boldsymbol M.
(15)

Here \boldsymbol F_w is the force of the walls and floor on the water, \boldsymbol F_p the pressure force at the inlet and outlet openings, and \boldsymbol W the water’s weight. The integral is momentum stored inside the control volume: \boldsymbol v is local velocity and d\mathcal V a small volume of water. Its time derivative accounts for acceleration of the water held inside the sump.

Even in steady flow, when that derivative is zero, pressure and weight remain in the balance. The water’s force on the structure is opposite to \boldsymbol F_w , and distributing it between individual walls needs more information again. The calculated M helps compare how much momentum two layouts redirect, but does not supply a wall design load.

Hydraulic depth and Froude number #

For a section with a free surface, let y be water depth above the invert and B the width of the water surface. The hydraulic depth, D_h , is

Dh=AB.D_h=\frac{A}{B}.
(16)
Hydraulic depth in a partly full pipe Partly full circular pipe showing wetted area A, water-surface width B and water depth y. Hydraulic depth is A divided by B, which differs from y in this pipe.BAyDₕ = A / BIn this pipe, Dₕ differs from y.

MiTS calculates its outer-wall rise from each pipe, so the generic width B becomes B_{inlet} or B_{outlet} . It equals y in a rectangular channel because A=By . In a partly full circular pipe, the width changes with depth, so hydraulic depth and water depth generally differ.

For small, long surface waves under the shallow-water approximation, wave speed relative to the water is c=\sqrt{gA/B}=\sqrt{gD_h} . The Froude number compares flow speed with that wave speed:

Fr=Vc=VgDh.Fr=\frac{V}{c}=\frac{V}{\sqrt{gD_h}}.
(17)

Take downstream as positive. Relative to the moving water, small surface disturbances can travel in either direction at speed c . To find their velocities relative to the ground, we add the flow velocity V :

Upstream-directed wave: V−c,Downstream-directed wave: V+c.\text{Upstream-directed wave: }V-c, \qquad \text{Downstream-directed wave: }V+c.
(18)

Here “upstream-directed” describes the wave’s motion relative to the water. Whether it reaches upstream relative to the ground depends on the flow regime:

  • Subcritical, Fr<1 : V<c , so V-c<0 and V+c>0 . Disturbances can travel both upstream and downstream.
  • Critical, Fr=1 : V=c , so V-c=0 . The upstream-directed wave is stationary relative to the ground, while the other travels downstream at V+c=2c .
  • Supercritical, Fr>1 : V>c , so both V-c and V+c are positive. Both waves move downstream relative to the ground.

These statements concern small, long surface waves; a moving hydraulic jump requires a separate analysis. See USACE, River Hydraulics, Section 2-2.

Wave motion in subcritical, critical and supercritical flowBoth ground-relative wave velocities in each flow regime. Subcritical: V minus c points upstream and V plus c downstream. Critical: V minus c is zero and V plus c points downstream. Supercritical: both point downstream. Wave motion relative to the ground Water flows downstream: V V − c V + c SubcriticalFr < 1, V < c UpstreamDownstream CriticalFr = 1, V = c StationaryDownstream SupercriticalFr > 1, V > c DownstreamDownstream Arrows show direction, not speed to scale.

These quantities belong to the chosen conduit section. They do not describe the whole sump. A full, pressurised pipe has no internal free surface, so this hydraulic-depth and surface-wave calculation does not apply there.

Why Fr = 1 marks critical flow and minimum specific energy #

The specific energy, E , is energy head measured above the local invert. For hydrostatic free-surface flow,

E=y+V22g=y+Q22gA(y)2.E=y+\frac{V^2}{2g}=y+\frac{Q^2}{2gA(y)^2}.
(19)

Why does critical flow occur at Fr=1 ? At fixed discharge and section geometry, increasing depth increases the first term but reduces velocity and hence the second. Critical energy is the minimum of their sum. Here A(y) reminds us that the wetted area changes with depth. A small depth increase dy adds an area approximately equal to B\,dy , so dA/dy=B .

Specific energy against depth at fixed discharge Curve of depth y against specific energy E for a fixed discharge in a rectangular section. Specific energy has a minimum at the critical depth, where the Froude number is one. The upper branch is subcritical and the lower branch is supercritical. A dashed line shows E equal to y.EyE = yCriticalMinimum EFr = 1Deeper, slower: subcritical, Fr < 1Shallower, faster: supercritical, Fr > 1Fixed discharge; rectangular section.

Keeping Q constant and differentiating Equation (19) gives

dEdy=1+Q22gddy(A−2).\frac{dE}{dy}=1+\frac{Q^2}{2g}\frac{d}{dy}\left(A^{-2}\right).
(20)

By the chain rule, d(A^{-2})/dy=-2A^{-3}(dA/dy) . Substituting this and cancelling the factor of two gives

dEdy=1−Q2gA3dAdy=1−Q2BgA3.\frac{dE}{dy}=1-\frac{Q^2}{gA^3}\frac{dA}{dy}=1-\frac{Q^2B}{gA^3}.
(21)

The fraction in Equation (21) looks different from the Froude-number formula in Equation (17). However, it is the same quantity squared, written in terms of discharge and section geometry. Start with Equation (17) and substitute the hydraulic depth from Equation (16):

Fr=VgDh=Vg(A/B).Fr=\frac{V}{\sqrt{gD_h}}=\frac{V}{\sqrt{g(A/B)}}.
(22)

We square both sides to remove the square root and compare this expression with the term in the energy derivative. Dividing by A/B is the same as multiplying by B/A :

Fr2=V2gDh=V2g(A/B)=V2BgA.Fr^2=\frac{V^2}{gD_h}=\frac{V^2}{g(A/B)}=\frac{V^2B}{gA}.
(23)

Finally, V=Q/A , so V^2=Q^2/A^2 . Substituting gives

Fr2=Q2A2BgA=Q2BgA3.Fr^2=\frac{Q^2}{A^2}\frac{B}{gA}=\frac{Q^2B}{gA^3}.
(24)

These are equivalent forms of the same definition. We use the velocity form to compare flow speed with wave speed, and the discharge form to recognise the term in the energy derivative:

dEdy=1−Q2BgA3=1−Fr2.\frac{dE}{dy}=1-\frac{Q^2B}{gA^3}=1-Fr^2.
(25)

At the critical depth, specific energy reaches its minimum, so

dEdy=0⟹1−Fr2=0⟹Fr=1.\frac{dE}{dy}=0 \quad\Longrightarrow\quad 1-Fr^2=0 \quad\Longrightarrow\quad Fr=1.
(26)

We take the positive root because Fr is defined here using speed. Thus the point where flow speed equals small-wave speed is also the point of minimum specific energy for the given discharge and section. This is the physical reason for the critical-flow condition. We can compare that minimum with the available specific energy when checking a channel control or possible choking.

A Froude number close to one deserves attention because a small change in the flow or geometry can change the regime. It also affects whether a regime-dependent formula can be used. It is not, on its own, a sump acceptance limit.

A consistent circular-pipe example #

Consider a 400 mm diameter pipe flowing 300 mm deep at 1.50 m/s:

The 400 mm pipe flowing 300 mm deep, drawn to scale Circular pipe of radius 0.20 m with water 0.30 m deep. The water surface is 0.10 m above the pipe centre and 0.346 m wide. The wetted central angle is 240 degrees, or 4 pi over 3 radians. Half the surface width, the radius and the 0.10 m offset form a right triangle.θ = 240°r0.10 mAB = 0.346 my = 0.30 mDrawn to scaleDiameter = 0.40 m, r = 0.20 mr − y = −0.10 m: surface above centreθ = 4π/3 radA = 0.10110 m²B = 0.34641 mDₕ = A/B = 0.29184 mDₕ differs from y

To calculate its Froude number we first need the wetted area and surface width. Let the radius be r=0.20 m and the wetted central angle be \theta , measured in radians:

θ=2cos⁡−1(r−yr)=2cos⁡−1(−0.5)=4π3.\theta=2\cos^{-1}\left(\frac{r-y}{r}\right)=2\cos^{-1}(-0.5)=\frac{4\pi}{3}.
(27)

The wetted area is the sector area r^2\theta/2 minus the signed triangle area r^2\sin\theta/2 . For the top width, half the surface chord forms a right triangle with sides r-y and r , so (B/2)^2=r^2-(r-y)^2 . Therefore,

A=r22(θ−sin⁡θ)=0.10110 m2,B=22ry−y2=0.34641 m.A=\frac{r^2}{2}(\theta-\sin\theta)=0.10110\ \text{m}^2, \qquad B=2\sqrt{2ry-y^2}=0.34641\ \text{m}.
(28)

Thus

Q=AV=0.15164 m3/s,Dh=0.101100.34641=0.29184 m,Q=AV=0.15164\ \text{m}^3/\text{s}, \qquad D_h=\frac{0.10110}{0.34641}=0.29184\ \text{m},
(29)
Fr=1.509.81(0.29184)=0.887,E=0.30+1.5022(9.81)=0.415 m.Fr=\frac{1.50}{\sqrt{9.81(0.29184)}}=0.887, \qquad E=0.30+\frac{1.50^2}{2(9.81)}=0.415\ \text{m}.
(30)

This section is subcritical. Notice that the water-surface width is 346 mm, although the pipe diameter is 400 mm. Substituting the diameter for the top width would change the answer.

Worked examples #

We will look at two cases: a sump that fails the rim check once its loss is included, and two layouts that both pass. Both use assumed values to illustrate the checks, and all elevations within each example use the same datum. We then ask whether including a loss raises the HGL everywhere.

When including the loss changes the decision #

Suppose a sump has a 90-degree turn and a rim elevation of 13.10 m. For this example, the acceptance limit is the rim itself, with no additional freeboard requirement.

Model case Sump-loss coefficient Assumed maximum node HGL Minimum rim clearance Result
Existing layout, sump loss omitted 0 13.03 m +0.07 m Pass
Same layout, sump loss included 1.00 13.14 m −0.04 m Fail
Straightened alternative 0.15 12.98 m +0.12 m Pass

Including the sump loss changes an apparent 70 mm clearance into a 40 mm exceedance of the limit. We already have a reason to revise the design, without calculating a local water-level rise. The engineer could change the alignment, capacity or levels, then rerun the model.

The straightened alternative is a different network layout. Its HGL must come from its own run; we cannot obtain it by subtracting the difference in K from the original water level. Likewise, comparing losses fairly requires consistent rainfall, downstream levels and other design inputs.

If an open node spills at its rim, the solver may limit the head and report flooding instead of the assumed 13.14 m head. A real project must use its actual node and ponding settings when checking this condition.

When both layouts stay below the rim #

Now consider a separate example with the same 13.10 m rim limit. The 90-degree layout and a straight-through alternative give the following assumed results:

90-degree layout and straight-through alternativeTwo plan sketches of a sump. Left: flow turns through 90 degrees, node HGL 13.03 m, with the local level at the outer wall unresolved by the node. Right: flow continues straight through, node HGL 12.94 m.90° turn inlet outlet outer wall local level unresolved by the node node HGL = 13.03 m Straight-through alternative inlet outlet (in line) node HGL = 12.94 m
Quantity 90-degree layout Straight-through layout
Preliminary K 1.00 0.15
Maximum node HGL 13.03 m 12.94 m
Minimum rim clearance 0.07 m 0.16 m
Modelled flooding None None

Both pass the stated rim check. Straightening gives another 90 mm of clearance. Whether that is worth the cost depends on the project.

To compare the loss and momentum calculations, suppose both layouts have Q=0.12\ \text{m}^3/\text{s} and V=1.50\ \text{m/s} at the selected reporting time, with equal inlet and outlet speeds. This implies a flow area of A=Q/V=0.080\ \text{m}^2 ; it is a separate example from the circular-pipe section above. In a real comparison, use each layout’s own simultaneous flow and velocity results.

First calculate velocity head:

hV=1.5022(9.81)=0.11468 m.h_V=\frac{1.50^2}{2(9.81)}=0.11468\ \text{m}.
(31)

Then the losses are

hL,90=1.00(0.11468)=0.11468 m,hL,0=0.15(0.11468)=0.01720 m.h_{L,90}=1.00(0.11468)=0.11468\ \text{m}, \qquad h_{L,0}=0.15(0.11468)=0.01720\ \text{m}.
(32)

Using each loss in Equation (10) gives

PL,90=1000(9.81)(0.12)(0.11468)≈135 W,P_{L,90}=1000(9.81)(0.12)(0.11468)\approx135\ \text{W},
(33)
PL,0=1000(9.81)(0.12)(0.01720)≈20.3 W.P_{L,0}=1000(9.81)(0.12)(0.01720)\approx20.3\ \text{W}.
(34)

For the turn, the momentum-flux change is

M90=2(1000)(0.12)(1.50)sin⁡45∘=254.6 N.M_{90}=2(1000)(0.12)(1.50)\sin45^\circ=254.6\ \text{N}.
(35)

For the straight path, \sin0^\circ=0 , so M_0=0 under the equal-flow, equal-speed assumptions. The chamber can still dissipate energy, as its nonzero K shows.

The turn therefore redirects more momentum and dissipates more energy in this comparison. If wall impact or lining durability is a concern, we would examine that layout first. Neither 135 W nor 255 N supplies an erosion or structural acceptance limit.

We can make a separate loss check if the project specifies an allowance. Suppose it allows at most 0.10 m of local head loss: the turned layout exceeds it by about 15 mm, while the straight layout passes. This allowance is an example, not a HEC-22 limit. Without such a requirement, a calculated loss of 0.115 m does not establish failure.

Does including K raise the HGL at every node? #

No. Whether a node’s peak HGL rises or falls depends on where the node sits relative to the added loss. We can see why from the energy balance and conservation of mass, before running any model.

Steady flow #

Take steady subcritical flow along one line of pipes, with the discharge and the downstream level held fixed. Rearranging Equation (7) gives

Hi=Ho+hL+Vo2−Vi22g.H_i=H_o+h_L+\frac{V_o^2-V_i^2}{2g}.
(36)

Adding a loss at a sump increases h_L , so the HGL just upstream of that sump rises. The nodes further upstream rise with it. The nodes downstream of the sump do not change, because their discharge and downstream level are unchanged. Thus in this steady case, a loss can only raise the HGL or leave it alone.

Storage during a storm #

A storm is not steady, and now two nodes behave differently. Node U lies upstream of the sump, where water is held in storage. Node D lies downstream, on the way to a fixed downstream level H_T :

Nodes upstream and downstream of a sump loss Long section. Inflow I enters storage S in the drains upstream of a sump with loss coefficient K. Node U lies in that storage. Outflow O leaves the sump and passes node D on its way to a fixed downstream level H T. The hydraulic grade line drops across the sump and then slopes down to the fixed level.HGLIOStorage SSump, KNode UHUNode DHDHTFixed level

Let S be the water stored upstream of the sump, with inflow I and outflow O through the sump. Conservation of mass gives

dSdt=I−O.\frac{dS}{dt}=I-O.
(37)

At a given upstream level, a larger loss lets less water through. If the head difference across the sump, \Delta H , all goes into the sump loss, then \Delta H=KV^2/(2g) , so

O=A2g ΔHK.O=A\sqrt{\frac{2g\,\Delta H}{K}}.
(38)

The same head difference therefore passes less flow when K is larger. To solve this in its simplest form, we approximate the outflow as proportional to the storage, O=aS , where a larger K means a smaller a . Then

dSdt=I−aS.\frac{dS}{dt}=I-aS.
(39)

The two nodes respond to different quantities. The HGL at node U follows the storage S . The HGL at node D follows the flow O reaching it:

HD=HT+hf(O),H_D=H_T+h_f(O),
(40)

where h_f is the friction loss in the pipe between node D and the fixed level, which grows with O . This is why a larger K can push the two nodes in opposite directions: it raises S but can lower O .

A long storm #

Take a long storm, with steady inflow I lasting until the storage settles. Setting dS/dt=0 in Equation (39) gives

O=I,S=Ia.O=I, \qquad S=\frac{I}{a}.
(41)

A smaller a increases S , so the HGL at node U rises. The outflow stays at I , so the HGL at node D does not change. This agrees with the steady calculation above.

A short burst #

Now take a short burst, where a volume S_0 arrives quickly and no further inflow follows. This is the case where the HGL falls. With no further inflow, Equation (39) reduces to dS/dt=-aS , which gives

S=S0e−at,O=aS0e−at.S=S_0e^{-at}, \qquad O=aS_0e^{-at}.
(42)

The plots below use S_0=1 , with a=1 without the added loss and a=0.5 with it:

Storage and outflow after a short burst, with and without the added loss Two plots against time, using a equal to 1 without the added loss and 0.5 with it. Left: storage at the upstream node starts at the same value and stays higher with the added loss. Right: outflow to the downstream node has a peak half as large with the added loss, and is higher only later.Storage S, sets the HGL at node UTime tOutflow O, sets the HGL at node DTime tPeak without the added lossLower peak with itHigher with the added lossWithoutWithout the added loss (a = 1)With the added loss (a = 0.5)

The plots show that with the loss included, the HGL at node U is higher, while the HGL at node D is lower early in the storm and higher later. So K does not have a single-direction effect on HGL.

What this means for the peak HGL #

The same added loss can raise the peak HGL upstream and lower it downstream. We therefore cannot obtain the new peak HGL by adding a node’s local head loss to its old peak. The size of each change depends on storage, timing and backwater, so for the numbers we need the routing run.

What about the water rising at the outside wall? #

Head loss measures energy dissipated as water passes through the sump. Superelevation is the water-surface difference across a turn, and it occurs even in an ideal curved flow with no energy loss. So we cannot obtain the rise at the outer wall from K .

The companion superelevation article derives that rise. MiTS reports two estimates of it, one from each connected pipe: the outer-wall rise using inlet results, \Delta h_{inlet} , and the outer-wall rise using outlet results, \Delta h_{outlet} . Head loss stays on the outlet speed, because that is how the K values above are defined.

Conclusion #

A one-dimensional model can tell us what an assumed sump loss does to the network. We take K from the deflection angle, or use our own value, and rerun the network. We then read the resulting node HGL and compare its minimum clearance below the rim with the project’s requirement. The loss is already in that HGL, so we do not add h_L again.

A one-dimensional model cannot compute two-dimensional quantities, such as the superelevation of water between the centreline and the outer wall of a sump or turning pipe. But we can still get some estimates from the model results by taking into account the sump geometry and Froude number, which will serve as a ballpark figure.

Powered by BetterDocs